Why We Fight
“Why We Fight” is writer/director Eugene Jarecki’s attempt to explain what drives American foreign policy in regards to military conflict. Sounds simple, eh?
One thing I want to mention off the bat is that like any documentary, especially one so politically charged, you have to watch them with a grain of salt. Whether it’s Michael Moore’s Bush bashing “Fahrenheit 9/11” or “Gunner Palace”, the film cannot be absolutely objective as a human being is behind the writing, filming and editing of the entire process.
It is impossible to present a narrative while being objective. The closest to objectivity is statement of fact without editorial, like in the news. Though of course, I think everyone worldwide is beginning to see that even the news slants their coverage to present it in their own fashion. While they may not lie about something, omitting an opposite viewpoint or misrepresenting something is just as bad.
All of that being said, “Why We Fight” focuses on the build up of the military-industrial complex since WW II. It takes a look at American foreign policy and its so-called imperialism over the last 60 years as our nation slowly but surely became the only superpower on the block. It tries to examine the mechanism behind how the government decides how to proceed in advancing military technology. It also reflects greatly on the effect 9/11 had on our collective psyche and individuals affected by it.
I don’t want to sit here and talk about the film too much, as almost anything I say will be an opinion and that’s what I don’t want to form in your minds. Even mentioning 9/11 is probably too much but I wanted people who read this to know you will see some footage from that day and I’m not really sure if that’s good or bad at this point.
I’m also not sure if using it in the film automatically sets the audience in a state more willing to accept what follows from the filmmaker. I am saying that one should keep an open, critical mind whenever watching any documentary and this is no exception.
Exceedingly relevant to current American foreign policy, “Why We Fight” provides a tight, well-put together documentary on the rationale behind the military-industrial complex and provides its audience with numerous talking points about not only the government’s motivations but whether or not we as citizens should be more critical and proactive in how the decisions are being made.
“Why We Fight” earns a 4 out of 5 from me and I STRONGLY urge everyone to see this film. Not to sound too melodramatic but I think this is a film that is every American’s duty to see so they can contemplate its content. Whether you fall on the right or left of the political mainstream, the historical lessons presented are too important for me to do anything but pimp this movie shamelessly.
I’m not saying everything in the film should be taken for granted. I just think it presents some viewpoints that should be considered and weighed against your own to help shape the overall outlook anyone should have in times as complicated as today.
One thing I want to mention off the bat is that like any documentary, especially one so politically charged, you have to watch them with a grain of salt. Whether it’s Michael Moore’s Bush bashing “Fahrenheit 9/11” or “Gunner Palace”, the film cannot be absolutely objective as a human being is behind the writing, filming and editing of the entire process.
It is impossible to present a narrative while being objective. The closest to objectivity is statement of fact without editorial, like in the news. Though of course, I think everyone worldwide is beginning to see that even the news slants their coverage to present it in their own fashion. While they may not lie about something, omitting an opposite viewpoint or misrepresenting something is just as bad.
All of that being said, “Why We Fight” focuses on the build up of the military-industrial complex since WW II. It takes a look at American foreign policy and its so-called imperialism over the last 60 years as our nation slowly but surely became the only superpower on the block. It tries to examine the mechanism behind how the government decides how to proceed in advancing military technology. It also reflects greatly on the effect 9/11 had on our collective psyche and individuals affected by it.
I don’t want to sit here and talk about the film too much, as almost anything I say will be an opinion and that’s what I don’t want to form in your minds. Even mentioning 9/11 is probably too much but I wanted people who read this to know you will see some footage from that day and I’m not really sure if that’s good or bad at this point.
I’m also not sure if using it in the film automatically sets the audience in a state more willing to accept what follows from the filmmaker. I am saying that one should keep an open, critical mind whenever watching any documentary and this is no exception.
Exceedingly relevant to current American foreign policy, “Why We Fight” provides a tight, well-put together documentary on the rationale behind the military-industrial complex and provides its audience with numerous talking points about not only the government’s motivations but whether or not we as citizens should be more critical and proactive in how the decisions are being made.
“Why We Fight” earns a 4 out of 5 from me and I STRONGLY urge everyone to see this film. Not to sound too melodramatic but I think this is a film that is every American’s duty to see so they can contemplate its content. Whether you fall on the right or left of the political mainstream, the historical lessons presented are too important for me to do anything but pimp this movie shamelessly.
I’m not saying everything in the film should be taken for granted. I just think it presents some viewpoints that should be considered and weighed against your own to help shape the overall outlook anyone should have in times as complicated as today.

4 Comments:
First time poster, long time reader…
I haven't had a chance to see this film, but that’s only because it’s not showing in my hole of an area. Some things compelled me to make a comment instead of usual activity of staring at an endless loop of Scott Stapp and Kid Rock being serviced by groupies.
I consider myself somewhat of a connoisseur of political documentaries, and there have been a slew of them in the recent past. The vast majority of these films are partisan in nature, and I could tell from the trailer that “Why We Fight” is no different. While it’s not as obviously slanted as “The Hunting of the President” or “Outfoxed”, it’s using the recent success of the best political documentary of all time – “The Fog of War”. This Errol Morris documentary is an example of how the filmmakers can be as removed from setting the tone as a result of their choices. This is only because the subject is so strong at setting the tone himself. Compounding that is that every message the movie seeks to reveal is much stronger because the principles set are left to the viewer to make the connections to the modern events that have made many of us so much more aware of the steps some governments take in the name of peace, freedom, or war.
If “Why We Fight” is half as good as “Fog of War”, then it’ll be a fantastic movie. I’m not sure if one is a better prelude to the other, but there isn’t a person I’ve met that I haven’t strongly urged to see “Fog of War” over any documentary of my knowledge.
Also, for an interesting take on the military industrial complex from a different perspective, check out the HBO movie “The Pentagon Wars”.
Time to go make some apple bomb for real chuck puckers…
Uhhh....you didn't review the Kid Rock /Scott Stapp Movie?
I missed that movie ... what a shame.
Actually, I'm okay with missing it. I don't like either of them with their clothes on or playing "music" so why should their latest endeavor spark any interest ... why am I even defending this point?!?
Well, I don't blame you,. I was referring to Bart who referenced it.
Post a Comment
<< Home